Szabályos hip check volt. Itt megint csak nem azért megy a reklamálás, ami történt, hanem mert Cooke volt az "elkövető". Már amennyiben szabályos megmozdulásnál elkövetőnek lehet nevezni az illetőt.

Edwards pedig a pittsburghi médiát kritizálja, amiért Cooke-ot jelölték Masterton awardra.

Amire itt a válasz egy pittsburghi bloggertől:

-For the record, the author of this blog is a member of the Professional Hockey Writers Association. We voted for Cooke as the Penguins' nominee for the Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy. Our reasoning was that Cooke's effort to correct and change his game met the criteria for the award which goes to the "player who best exemplifies the qualities of perseverance, sportsmanship, and dedication to hockey." Those characteristics all describe what Cooke did in cleaning up and improving his game.

-The award sometimes gets incorrectly described as a "comeback player" award for someone who rebounds from an injury or some other ailment. It's not always the case. Cooke showed an incredible amount of fortitude last season in making himself a better, cleaner player.